Aveneu Park, Starling, Australia

The Changing Employee Relations At Nat Bank Essay

The impression of work topographic point partnership was a cardinal docket of the New Labour Government ‘s employment policy of ‘modernisation ‘ and gained drift and became an built-in component to specify the characteristic of industrial dealingss for the new millenary ( Martinez- Lucio and Stuart, 2004: 410 ) . Ackers and Payne ( 1998 ) realized that partnership as a new HRM tendency looked imperative to bring on brotherhoods back to the centre of employment dealingss ( Cited in Johnstone et. al. , 2009 ) . Besides it was at the nucleus of the new docket of ‘fairness at Work ‘ set out by the Blair Government ( DTI, 1998 ) . Although the UK partnership argument may be a comparatively recent phenomenon, the subject has attracted a signii¬?cant sum of research attending since 1998, including regular particular watercourses at employment dealingss conferences ( Johnstone et. al. , 2009 ) . So one can deduce that since its development that is in late 1990s the partnership concept has been a subject of argument with its significance in beef uping employee- employer relationship.

The paper has done the literature reappraisal in visible radiation of the instance of NatBank, that ‘s the major UK bank using over 100000 people worldwide and 60000 in the UK. To brief about the scenario it is imperative to cognize that the bank got into a partnership understanding after a really hapless clime of industrial dealingss of late 1990s, climaxing in industrial action over wage in 1997 ( Johnstone, 2009 ) .

In visible radiation of the literature on ‘social partnership ‘ , this paper has done elucidation of its significance, failings and strengths as a means to develop sustainable employee – employer relationship for fiscal organisation as NatBank. In the terminal the paper has provided certain critical recommendations to the Bank in order to develop and beef up its employee relationship from a futuristic point of position.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Employee Relationship at NatBank

The relationship amongst employee and employer was wobbly during the 1990s. One of the grounds for the same was a dark relationship amongst the Union and the Company taking to holds and long figure of yearss spent to decide jobs, said one of the employee relationship director of NatBank. This got aggravated with issues like public presentation related wage, staggered displacement forms, altering of contracts from the original NatBank contracts to Flexi contracts with small pecuniary wagess ( Johnstone et. al. , 2010 ) . One of the grounds for such drastic alteration was the displacement of the traditional banking from a conservative manner of banking of station war period to new banking system of 1980s and 1990s which led to reforms in the industry due to increasing globalisation and to be competitory efforts were made to alter the organisation civilization, staffing and pay, got worsened with occupation redundancies due offshoring of concern to India ( Storey et. al. , 1997, Stuart and Martinez-Lucio, 2008 ) . Hence such revolution and alteration to the industry wholly led to an industrial action, which so led the Bank to acquire into a partnership understanding with the Union to turn to certain important issues in the twelvemonth 2000. The paper now discusses how those of import issues were addressed, as those were the chief causes of the altering employee relationship at the Bank.

Factors of altering employee dealingss


Offshoring was one chief ground for the unrest amongst the employees, as most of the clerical work was so outsourced to India and people so were offered to work as telephone based client advisers. This was a drastic alteration and a batch of old employees resisted to this alteration, besides this led to occupation redundancies, worry due to occupation insecurity, which finally led to employees think that the brotherhood is crap. One of the rules of societal partnership was based on easing alteration direction at the same clip guaranting involvement of the employees is secured ( Johnstone et. al. , 2010 ) .

The partnership agreement led to a model of avoiding mandatory redundancies in instance of offshoring for which there were cardinal commissariats made as the portion of the understanding ( Johnstone et. al. , 2010 ) as follows:

Enhanced usage of voluntary Job matching.

Redeployment to another section where the work is carried out by contractual or bureau worker on test.

In arrangement and out- arrangement support by advisers.

Extra preparation support to promote possibilities of external retraining.

Now, all this was made possible as a consequence of treatment and engagement of the representatives with the direction determination doing procedure when it was in the design phase, which was non the instance during pre-partnership yearss. Engagement of the Union in the procedure led to decrease of 1000 occupation cuts to meager 225, guaranting first-class rupture strategies for the displaced ( Johnstone at. Al, 2010 ) .

Re- scaling

Due the alteration of functions to more telephone based occupation, where most determinations were system based, this led to an re- rating of the classs with an purpose to cut down it from rating 3 to rate 2, which would otherwise hold had a inauspicious impact on the employee ‘s morale. By affecting Union in the determination devising procedure, it was so decided to maintain the classs of the bing employees at the same degree and instead enrolling the new 1s at the new class of degree 2. This would hold otherwise been forced on the work force with no or small audience. Hence, one can deduce that the agreement of consultancy with the brotherhood had a positive and a successful impact on the employees on this forepart ( Johnstone at. Al, 2010 ) .

Flexible Contracts

One other issue that drastically affected employee relation and was the chief cause of altering relationship with the company is alteration to the employment contracts of the employees to do it more flexible from a regular 9-5 to more of 24/7 atmosphere. This move was indispensable from the concern and client services position ; nevertheless it had a negative morale on the bing staff. So in order to maintain the morale high for the long term success of the Bank, Union had a consensus with the company non to alter the contract for the bing staff, but instead employee new people with new contract to function this facet of the concern. So this another success of the partnership understanding and was of the nucleus factors of altering employee relationship, and it finally led to a win- win state of affairs ( Johnstone at. Al, 2010 ) .

Gross saless and Service Split

The civilization was switching from pure service oriented to more gross revenues driven, where in staff members were forced or pressurized to set it nicely to do cross gross revenues on most eligible calls. This led batch of employees, leave the administration as non everyone could sell and therefore could take the force per unit area of gross revenues. This led Union to acquire into consultancy with the direction to divide the gross revenues and service split, and apportioning the staff consequently based on single accomplishments which to an extent served the rule of the understanding of the partnership that is run intoing client outlooks by holding right people with the right accomplishments in the right topographic point. So, people with a nag towards gross revenues were allocated towards gross revenues and the remainder were led to concentrate on the service portion of it. This manner once more with the engagement in the procedure the brotherhood created win-win state of affairs for the concern and the staff ( Johnstone at. Al, 2010 ) .

So overall one can measure the grounds for the alteration in employee relationship and the significance of the societal partnership played by the brotherhood. However, the other side of the narrative lies in certain challenges faced by this sort of agreement. Though the agreement proposed consultancy at during the procedure at the design phase of any determination, nevertheless the concluding determination lied in the custodies of the direction. Representatives or histrions of the brotherhood can measure the determinations made by the direction in visible radiation of the 6 rules on which the agreement was based and offer needed remarks or options. However few histrions found this sort of agreement folly and hard to understand. Besides as a batch of times employees merely get to hear the results and are non posted about the procedure of the determinations involved, this posed a menace to a few representatives to be perceived to be in entire control of the direction and being biased. Hence, this paper has done a literature reappraisal of the construct of societal partnership and so provides needed recommendation to the brotherhood of NatBank to develop a sustainable relationship during the times of economic hurt or organizational turbulence.

Concept of Social Partnership

The construct of societal partnership as a consequence of built-in ambiguity has been described as

“ An thought with which about anyone can hold, without holding any clear thought what they are holding to ” ( Guest and Peccei, 2001:207, cited in Johnstone et.al. , 2009 ) .

Guest and Peccei ( 2001 ) besides stated that mutualness and trust are two cardinal elements of echt partnership understanding. As per Stuart and Martinez ( 2005a ) stated that partnership is an preposition for an employer which entails it to be both economically effectual and ethically responsible to cooperative with Employees and Unions on the topic of strategic organizational alteration. There have been many a definitions and various positions on the construct of partnership, nevertheless most seem to hold a common subject of mutualness, cooperation, audience, coaction or joint working between the brotherhoods and the employer. Partnership is a sort of rejuvenating strategic tool for the brotherhoods by which they have argued that the modern-day capitalist economy demands to suit employees and brotherhoods as a constructive voice, negociating and lending to the overall organizational alteration and productiveness ( TUC, 1997, Cited Wills, 2004 ) . The apprehension of partnership UK is though is rather different from the traditional impression prevailed as regulative European Social Model ( Johnstone et. Al, 2009 ) nevertheless it is based on six nucleus constituents and those constituents are designed to guarantee that brotherhoods can be effectual without complacent about the organizational success ( Wills, 2004 ) and those as per TUC ( 1997 ) are as follows:

Guarantees of employment security.

Committedness to organizational success.

Openness and transparence.

Recognition of overlapping but distinguishable involvements.

Enhancing the quality of working life.

Taping the motive, committedness and invention of the employees to do the work interesting and value adding

Having looked the construct of societal partnership, the paper now discusses the strengths and the failings of the construct.

Strengths of Social partnership

Influencing determinations:

One of the cardinal benefits of societal partnership is its ability to act upon determinations in the procedure phase by acquiring into audience manner right from the initial proposal of alteration. This is rather apparent from the instance of NatBank the virtues discussed before in this paper. This was chiefly the chief ground for set uping the altering employee dealingss at the Bank.

Common additions:

From the first portion of the paper an illation can easy been drawn that partnership in instance of NatBank has led to common benefits, as increasing or keeping the morale of employees is indispensable for the long term fiscal success of the company ( Stated before ) . In line with same impression Kochan and Osterman ( 1994 ) stated that common additions can one stop lead to better dickering power over flexibleness, development, employment security and engagement and on the other terminal employers can be benefitted with improved dealingss with the brotherhood, aid of facilitation of alteration ( Johnstone et. al. , 2009 ) . Adding to the same statement Marchington ( 1998 ) added that this agreement can assist the brotherhoods to hold greater entree to information, occupation security and inter brotherhood cooperation.

Quality focussed competetive scheme:

Kochan ( 1995 ) argue that partnership understanding may take to development of organizational constructions that induce integrative, joint additions solutions will ensue in more employee friendly organizational civilizations that may take to high employee morale, better occupation satisfaction and will ensue in quality focused competitory scheme that may non be available in the forsaking of corporate bargaining ( Cited in Roche and Geary, 2002 ) . This impression to a great extent has been exemplified by Gennard ( 2001 ) who while measuring the principle for Public Policy Development ( 1997-2001 ) in one of his article, he observed that the Blair authorities in its quest to construct a competitory economic system focused on employee engagement in direction determination devising procedure which enhances employee ‘s committedness to their employer ensuing in greater productiveness, taking to being competitory.

Local determination devising:

Another benefit reaped from societal partnership particularly in the instance of NatBank is its ability to construct solid cell of local representatives. These representatives were close to the existent concern, knowing and as a portion of their function could oppugn, challenge and carry the direction to do necessary alterations to the approaching determination, avoiding escalation of issues and unneeded holds in the whole procedure ( Johnstone at. al. , 2009 ) .

Failings of societal partnership

Pseudo Engagement:

Kelly ( 1996, 1998, 1999 ) has done critiquing of the societal partnership based the fact that such partnerships were more employer dominated in footings of cooperation. Kelly ( 1999 ) besides set out analyzing several other partnership in UK, where his determination were once more black demoing companies endangering to de-regularize brotherhoods every bit good as neglecting to honour corporate understandings meant to keep employee ‘s employment security and competitory rewards. Adding to the same impression Streeck ( 1992, 1994, 1995 ) stated his statement based on dissymmetry of power between direction and organized labor. He besides stated that involvement of the brotherhood in a partnership concept is seen to be accorded legitimacy by direction merely to the extent that they serve peculiar market maps. This was besides apparent in the instance of NatBank when certain histrions had jobs with the fact that even though they had the chance to notice, inquiry and propose options, the ultimate determination still lies with the direction.

Lack of Partnership civilization and engagement:

This was apparent peculiarly in the instance of NatBank that the company lacked the civilization of partnership and engagement. This was one of the grounds why even though there was perfect coordination amongst the senior direction, the brotherhood functionaries and the representatives, there lied some kind of gulf with the line directors, who were responsible to acquire the nucleus occupation done. This was besides apparent from the fact that the even though the employees did look to swear the brotherhood, nevertheless they showed small involvement in them, as all they get to cognize is the concluding result of the procedure and non the audience portion of it. This finally made the employees skeptical about the unity of the representatives and the brotherhood as they might see them to be merely direction poodles ( Johnstone, 2009 ) .

Decision and recommendation

From the literature reappraisal and the instance of NatBank it is apparent and clear that the intent of a societal partnership is to hold a transparent, participative, collaborative and unfastened civilization in an administration to do the determination doing procedure more balanced in footings of the people and concern facets, therefore protecting the involvement of the employees every bit good as the guaranting concern fight. The whole procedure purposes at treatments and apprehension of any major determination to be made and to discourse the involvement of the parties involved chiefly, the concern and the employees. However for the procedure of audience and representation it is imperative to hold complete and appropriate engagement by the employees at all degrees. This entails the really demand of bring oning a participative civilization promoting employees to straight voice out their concerns and apprehensivenesss at all degrees. The communicating in the instance discussed in this paper had majorly been top-down, which does non supply the right model for direct engagement of the employees. Hence the paper has certain recommendation to be made to NatBank or similar administrations in order to supply a model for sustainable execution of the societal partnership concept:

The company needs to implement supportive HR patterns together with the publicity of strategic integrating between HR and strategic direction.

The implicit in direction thought and doctrine demands to be made contributing to advance the overall civilization of engagement at all degrees.

The company should promote engagement of the employees by non merely following the top-down communicating attack, but should supply adequate infinite and a frame work like a focal point group, employee study and other chances to the employees to voice out their positions and concerns to be a portion of determination devising for the concern.


I'm Simon!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out